I think Star made very good points. You are focusing on the "it won't work" part of this.
Our kids NEED us to be super flexible - like a sideshow attraction.
We HAVE to learn new skills constantly. We HAVE to come to terms with our own grief, the grief for that wonderful baby, child, adult we were ready to raise. It stins, and is super hard.
We also have to get out of our own way. Sometimes we need to make SURE the tdocs and psychiatrists and others SEE our kids in their full difficult child-glory. Otherwise they don't believe us and can't/won't help us. Take videos. It really helps.
I did something rather controversial while my son was in psychiatric hospital. After many weeks of honeymooning I could see they were sending him home soon. Without addressing any of the problems. They believed me, but they "can't treat what they don't see".
I made them see it. I went into therapy, with advance warning to the therapist, and triggered every behavior I could. It sounds so very cruel, even to me.
I was fighting for his LIFE. Not just him being able to be productive, to live outside of prison, but for his LIFE. At 11 he had a history of serious suicide attempts. I can live with a day of "cruel" button pushing. I can't imagine living after my baby killed himself. (Your difficult child is not showing this, I just want to show you MY mindset)
He exploded. Violent, foul mouthed, destructive, hideous. He spilled all sorts of stuff I didn't know he had done. MOSTLY stuff he had done to his little sister, some to his little brother.
That was the day our healing started.
We ALL had to learn new ways to behave. I took all sorts of parenting classes, husband did when his schedule allowed, and he juggled that schedule like he had gone to Clown College! The other kids, and my parents, all were going to therapy.
It took radical shifts in thinking and behavior. He is now a junior, all college prep classes finished by the end of this year, and a 2 year vocational program in place and paid for through grants.
You are adamantly against so many things. That is your right. We will support you. But we do have some experience and information.
One piece is that mental illness is most likely a result of mis-wiring in the brain or of brain chemistry problems. If the solution is physical, then sometimes a physical solution is needed. (NOT talking about spanking, hitting, or other types of violence - those jsut don't help.) If his brain chemistry is off so much that he can't function, and that he can't make safe choices, then he may need chemicals to balance things. And medication is a tough, long, scary path. We want a quick fix. But it isn't there. Even after teh medications are at the right level it takes weeks or months to see if they work.
If his brain is wired differently, then there may be things to help fix the wiring. In children with sensory integration disorder the brushing therapy literally helps create new pathways in the brain. Other therapies can help like this with SOME disorders.
From been there done that, when we dealt with the brain chemistry imbalances, and with the physical problem of tooooo much sensory input from living with too many other kids, my son turned around. Very little of the manipulation, no violence, and a reasonably happy kid.
If we had insisted he stay in a situation that overloaded him (life at home with husband, me, and his 2 sibs) he would not have recovered. If we had not paid attention to his brain chemistry problems (unipolar depression) then he would still be suicidal, if he was alive.
While medications are very scary, so are the diseases. I know the pull of school, work, money, lack of family support. been there done that. I was HORRIFIED to learn that biplar has a MORTALITY rate of 30% (the bipolar child - first version), and depression also has a very high mortality rate.
What kinds of interventions do you think would help? You don't have to post them here, but write them down. Be as specific as possible - when he starts to rage, it would help to XYZ. Then you have more of an idea what to ask for when you go for help at school, the DV shelter, etc... (and you may need a supervisor to get help there - often the first level people are just out of school and don't know all the ropes).
Try the support groups. Go 4 or 5 times to each one that feels appropriate. It will be enough to get you over the "new person" feeling and to get a true idea of the feel, direction, and possibilities. I would bet good $$$ that MANY of the peopel there with kids have dealt with some level of violence from them.
Sorry so long. I got wordy again. I do understand the dislike, even hating, of medications foryour kids. I DO support you. I think if you can read some books about the working of the brain in children who have any types of disorders similar to your kids it would help. NOT help you see that "medications are the only way" but see what specifically may help your child.