Anyone who has a problem with used toys has lost the meaning of the holidays, in my opinion. I do agree that anything a baby is going to really chew on, like a teether, should be new. And mostly shoes should be, and of course food. Anything else can be used. We have had a limit of $10 to $15 for gifts to adults on my side of the family for almost 20 years. Some years we have a theme like toys from our childhoods, or hobbies, or whatever. But usually not. We buy used to get items that the other person really WANTS, or we buy supplies and make the items. One year I worked an estate sale and got a Lenox cardinal statue that after the discount for working the sale and for it not selling the first day ended up at 59 cents over the limit - and that was fine. Cardinals were always on a card or letter or ornament that my gma sent for Christmas - my mom's stepmom. When I saw the cardinal I KNEW that it was the perfect gift for my mom. MOST of our gifts are used or experience gifts.
WHen you don't know what a child would like, or the child has more stuff than they can really enjoy, consider giving an experience. A class in some craft or skill they want to learn, dance lessons, a camping trip, horseback riding lessons, a trip to a ropes course, have several of their friends over to decorate cookies or make ornaments or do some craft. For a CSI buff teach fingerprinting and some other basic CSI type stuff. You can do fingerprinting with some cheap makeup or paint brushes (eyeslipsface.com has some excellent ones for $1 each that work perfectly) and powdered sugar, cocoa powder, baby powder, baking soda, etc..... It is SUPER easy. I can give you sites to help with that. If magic tricks are something a child is interested in, take a LOOK at some of the big kits of tricks at the stores, then go to a real magic store (often a costume and/or party store also) and get some REAL tools. Usually they have some great videos on how to do tricks too. We did that with thank you one year. We bought some small tricks and then gave him a budget to buy some bigger items like a hat. Then he got a trip and choose the items he really wanted. We did discourage him from buying more than one of the scarves and then had him help gma make a couple more of them.
If a child likes building things, and is able to be trusted to not hurt others with the tools, check out Sears and Home Depot for kids' tools. Also consider getting some tools that are not marketed to kids but are of a size to fit a child's hands. Years back we got a nice bag to keep tools in and some craftsman tools for Wiz, and added some tools from the dollar store and walmart to fill the gift out.
If the girls are interested in jewelry, make your own kit with various findings, beads, wire, tools, and include some costume jewelry from thrift stores and your own unwanted/broken jewelry. Put it into a nice box or plastic storage organizer (craft stores often have some awesome organizers but if you don't see hwat you want in the bead area, check sewing, scrapbooking, and other areas to see if they have something better suited for what you want) and it will be a better, and often cheaper, gift that will last far longer than the kits that you would buy.
My kids know that they get many gifts from yard sales, thrift stores, sales etc... and they are happy about it. They know they get better gifts, ones more suited to what they want/like and ones that we otherwise couldn't afford. Jessie esp LOVES thrift stores for clothes because her friends are ALWAYS asking about her clothes - where she got them, how she afforded them, etc.... Used to be the kids bragged about their brand names and how much they spent. then along came my girl and now? They brag about how little they spent, the hunt for what they wanted, what idiots the other kids are for spending so much on their clothes, how they embellish/alter the clothes to make what they want. A couple of the moms were upset with me at first, two even called me to gripe. One said that just because we were "poor" was no reason to tell her child to go wear clothes that other people had worn. I laughed - asked what the problem was? After all, her daughter that is J's age was always wearing handmedowns from her sister and cousins. Used clothes get washed, and are just handmedowns from people you don't know, aren't they?
Six months later the same mom thanked me, said they were saving so much by going to 2nd hand stores and yard sales that they were taking an extra vacation and would be able to afford a car when the older daughter was ready to drive - with-o taking out a loan. Seems that J's friend talked her mom into buying other used things. Now they are avid freecyclers too.
Jess never intended to do that, to influence the other girls. She just didn't see the logic in buying clothes at new prices, even at some of the walmart prices, when thrift stores had so many things and such variety. Some of her friends even get together to go yard saling once a month or so as a group.
If you have an avid yard-saler, consider getting an area map and having it laminated. Then you can list the sales you want to go to, mark them on the map with an overhead projection marker (vis a vis brand is one, dry erase may also work, we just always had the overhead markers around - if you accidentally use a sharpie, it will come off with alcohol) and go to the sales in order of whatever is closest. yes, you can also use yahoo driving directions, but using a map can be more helpful in some ways. It also teaches map skills so if you have a kid going with you it is an important skill for them to learn.
Janet, I do think Billie would have a fit over used toys. But I sure wouldn't buy any new ones for her kids either. NOT with the way they treat you and their toys. So take a used toy and put it in a custom wrapping - a gift bag made out of cloth that it could be stored in, etc.... Or for legos, try a tool box that they could be stored in, etc..... Mabye for dolls with clothes, etc.... make a storage box like the old wardrobes for barbie dolls that used to be around? I never had a kid into dolls, so I don't know what all is available for them. Jessie wanted real kitchen equipment by the age of 3, and tools before that, and art supplies mostly.
You can disguise the "used" part of gifts if you put them into a kit or bag/box that can be used for storage. Be sure to check the paper mache boxes sold at craft stores that you can paint/decorate - this makes the gift "handmade" and custom rather than "used", in my opinion. At least they seem that way.
For new gifts, be sure to check hospital gift shops. They often have really interesting items that you might not find elsewhere and their pricing can be strange. At the hospital J was in, some items seemed too expensive, like $15 reusable travel coffee cups that were not dishwasher safe, and some were surprisingly cheap, like hte $3.50 six piece manicure set that came in a really nice, sturdy box and had the tools had the same stripes or polka dots or whatever that the box had. Then they had some really NICE lip balm in fun flavors for $1 that I have seen in other stores for $3 to $5. Around here the hospitals also have the newest stuffed animals at prices that are less than most other stores - not just thank you brand, but Gund, Dakin, even Steiff.