Obama's plan would provide a "public option" to compete with private insurance. The deal is that if someone is denied coverage, or the premiums are too costly, an individual would have the option of having coverage through the public health plan which would not deny someone based on a previous condition. So, the public plan would compete directly with private insurance companies. The theory is that costs (and premiums) would go down because private insurance companies would then have to complete with the government plan.
Arguments for:
*We are the only industrialized nation that does not have a national public health care plan.
*A large percentage of bankruptcies in this country are due to medical bills which are recouped in higher medical costs (we pay already).
*Private insurance companies primary objective is to make a profit for its shareholders which is in direct conflict with the service they are suppose to provide, quality health care. In other words, they are in the business of providing as little health care as possible to realize the largest profit possible.
Against:
*The government can't operate Social Security and Medicare efficiently, they certainly won't be able to run a national health care plan efficiently.
*Allow businesses, and private individuals, to choose plans out of state as to increase competition and lower costs. As it is, plans can only be chosen from those that operate within a state.
*We need Tort reform, first. Medical malpractice suits are in the billions already. Imagine the greed if people were now allowed to sue the government for medical malpractice.
I deliberately left out controversial points of view and tried to fairly give perspectives from both sides. Of course, it is more complicated, but those are a few of the main arguments I have been reading about over the past months. Honestly, I think both sides really have some good points and all need to be thoughtfully considered. I am really disgusted about what is going on right now with the mudslinging.
I think that everyone pretty much agrees that we desperately need health care reform, it's just how and what, exactly, is where some people seem to lose to their senses.