Malika
Well-Known Member
We are all jumping to a lot of conclusions here, which is inevitable since we do not know the child concerned, or the context, and we all have a natural tendency to read our own situations in others'... I would really want to know more about what has led up to this incident with the cat and with the general aggression and hostility... The boy has a lot of diagnoses. I know that ODD lends itself to explosiveness, which often involves violence. Was he always difficult and disturbed in his behaviour or is it a more recent phenomenon? Is there an attachment problem? Would you say that you were securely bonded with him in the past, wethreepeeps, and that this has changed? Being adopted at age three and being adopted at a much later age would be a significant difference, for example.
As for cruelty to animals in children... Even this is complex and not straightforward, I feel. Until my parents divorced when I was 7, we lived next door to a family who seemed unhappy - the father was seen beating a dog with a rake and was authoritarian and unsympathetic with his children. I do not remember the mother but seem to recall there were problems in the marriage... I used to love birds and birdwatching and when I was six or so, I would go roaming the next door woods with the little boy of the family (a bit older than me - 8?) - in the days when children did go off by themselves and nobody worried. We used to look for birds and their nests and found a family of young thrushes that we used to go and see daily. One day my friend did not come with me and I went into the woods alone - there, to my shock, I found the thrush nest with all the baby bird's heads cut off as though with a pair of secateurs... I was obviously very distressed and went home to tell what I had seen. It emerged that it was my friend who had done it... I remember the father standing in the road screaming at him all the horrible ways he was going to be punished...
When I look back at this incident as an adult I do not think of my young friend as a future psychopath. He was clearly disturbed, in ways we had not realised... but he was expressing in a very graphic way the brutality and unhappiness that surrounded him... children do do this. It does not necessarily mean they are inherently violent or dangerous. They also may be those things - I am just saying that the picture is not so simple.
And of course I do not know what is going on with this boy... I do feel sadness for him, though, because he does not know how to love or be loved and he is in the midst of endangering his home life, for others and for himself. That does indeed seem to me worthy of compassion.
As for cruelty to animals in children... Even this is complex and not straightforward, I feel. Until my parents divorced when I was 7, we lived next door to a family who seemed unhappy - the father was seen beating a dog with a rake and was authoritarian and unsympathetic with his children. I do not remember the mother but seem to recall there were problems in the marriage... I used to love birds and birdwatching and when I was six or so, I would go roaming the next door woods with the little boy of the family (a bit older than me - 8?) - in the days when children did go off by themselves and nobody worried. We used to look for birds and their nests and found a family of young thrushes that we used to go and see daily. One day my friend did not come with me and I went into the woods alone - there, to my shock, I found the thrush nest with all the baby bird's heads cut off as though with a pair of secateurs... I was obviously very distressed and went home to tell what I had seen. It emerged that it was my friend who had done it... I remember the father standing in the road screaming at him all the horrible ways he was going to be punished...
When I look back at this incident as an adult I do not think of my young friend as a future psychopath. He was clearly disturbed, in ways we had not realised... but he was expressing in a very graphic way the brutality and unhappiness that surrounded him... children do do this. It does not necessarily mean they are inherently violent or dangerous. They also may be those things - I am just saying that the picture is not so simple.
And of course I do not know what is going on with this boy... I do feel sadness for him, though, because he does not know how to love or be loved and he is in the midst of endangering his home life, for others and for himself. That does indeed seem to me worthy of compassion.