This is a very very very old thread. These posters are mostly long gone. But I will respond. I probably did the first time.
I will again disagree that it is okay, in 2018, to let kids go wild and unchecked.
In the olden days...hehe...sure, most kids survived lack of close supervision. I will say this was more true in close small neighborhoods. And the ones who were victims of lack of supervision are not around to tell their stories.
Also, I live near the Amish. They never buckle their kids in to the carriages and believe that whatever happens is God's will, death included. Accidents and deaths of children in carriages are common. But....I degress.
I can only go by where I live today. I can't speak for other areas. I am sure some are safer than others with different dynamics as they always are and were.
Drugs in 2018 in my neck of the woods are rampant, worse than ever before. Crime is almost all drug related. I know this for a fact as my daughter is a Corrections Officer at our local jail. What would a young kid wandering around alone possibly encounter today that he or she didn't thirty years ago?
Well, needles from sick drug addicts and with dangerous drugs still in them are thrown around in woods, parks and regular parking lots. This is a new danger to littles in our area. Drug needles for little ones to pick up and play with. The dangerous drugs in this country are worse than ever. The addiction rate is a crisis and not limited to poor neineighborho or the indoors. I never thought of this, never looked for a discarded needle. I learned a lot from my daughter.
Sexual predators live amongst us. I don't know if they always did. They do now. Many people who survived a lack of supervision were abused in our day and age but I wonder if it was more family then. Now they are stranger predators all over too and everywhere. The difference then is it was taboo to discuss children preyed upon. But it happened. It possibly happens more now.
School used to be safe. Who heard of a school shooting??! Biggest horror was being sent to a scary principal! Right? Well, welcome to school shootings!. Cable news and the internet has now glorified this act in the minds of some disturbed teens and made school shootings bonechillingly common place. They don't shock us when we hear about another one.
Also, aside from that, kids from all over seem to have cars, so parents don't know the strangers who drive into town. Are they drug dealers with guns? Predators? Violent? Mrs. Smith who knows everyone who lives in Pleasant City can not know everyone anymore who drives through it. Your child is not watched as closely. by the butcher, the baker, the candlestick maker. Most mothers work. Nobody is home when Sara comes home from school. Nobody can see what she is doing or who is harassing her on her way home. Or what she is smoking.
Do you live in a big city? I lived in Chicago for two years well over twenty years ago. It was unsafe then. I can imagine now. In a big city you don't know your neighbors. You never did. Unstable people you don't know are everywhere. Sorry, but anyone who let a little kid wander around alone in Chicago even twenty years ago was in my opinion very negligent. Today? Forget it. Drive by shootings??
As for the usual banter "I got spanked and I'm okay" many got beaten or whooped and aren't okay. There is a reason we have laws against whooping. Do I think spanking a padded butt is bad? No. Helpful? For the moment, if the kid is three it may stop behavior. In the big picture, only if you escalate to beatings. Heck, these days older kids whoop their parents back. It does not cause your kids to respect you, at least not now.
Are kids more uncontrollable today? Maybe. I'm not so sure. But they are in more danger and the internet allows communication with perfect strangers and most of us allow this by purchasing cell phones and computers for even off the rails kids. Go back to elementary school kids, our grandkids. Take an eight year old on a computer and you can see what future dangers can happen to little kids. Very young kids do computers now. Kids of millennials. They will communicate with strangers too...they are growing up with this skill of computer communication. If Mom is at work and the sitter is lazy...who supervises the internet?
More than ever I feel it is important to watch your little precious kids, although twenty years ago in Chicago you still should not have let six year olds run around the neighborhood. When I lived there I was 21 and I was scared. And I lived in a "good" area in Chicago but still had a few scary encounters. And I did not feel safe. It is NOT safe everywhere. It never was and today it is worse than before. Yet, with divorce and single parenting, more littles are on their own. Many twelve year olds are without supervision after school, free to have sex, do drugs and be assaulted. To me it is scary.
I believe, but not from experience, that years ago small, close-knit towns with mothers and grandmas at home to watch the neighborhood kids it was safer. I still think it is safer in smaller towns. But no longer safe as in SAFE. Safer than Chicago, but not safe.
This is just my opinion. I don't feel we can do what we did fifty years ago or even twenty years ago. in my opinion cars are the biggest problem. Everyone has one. Anyone can visit your town. Drugs are a nightmare. Violence has escalated. If I had a kid now, I would be vigilant. Actually, I always was.
Well, just my .02.