Abby is great from 11 pm till 7 am. then she goes out multiple times, every 20 minutes or so. Unless we are all out of the house, then she is crated. But thankfully all of us are not gone for more than 2 hours. My problem is I take her out to pee and before our 20 minutes is up, she will pee a quarter size amount anywhere! Its like, ah, you just peed outside!!!