That is the question for today. We've all heard the argument and battles that have ensued in homes where the toilet seat is left up or down, but this thread relates to the actual toilet lid itself. In our house I like the lid shut. Can't tell you how many times I have dropped something in the toilet or had something roll off the counter and right into the toilet over the years with the lid up. P.S. We need fun threads like these to help guide us in a different direction and add a little comedy and fun into our life. Helps keep life light.